Back when I still followed and enjoyed baseball, there was a magazine I read called Baseball Digest, which featured a column titled ‘So You Think You Know Baseball?’, where a rare or unusual moment from a game – usually one that required a check of the rulebook – was presented, and the reader was tasked with making the correct call. Now, for my SP78 Replay season, I’ll let you make the call, on a play that occurred during an August 12th match-up between the Astros and Braves at the Astrodome, whose result you’ll be hard-pressed to find in any baseball rulebook.
First, I’ll set the stage. With the game scoreless with two out in the top of the second, Braves second baseman Glenn Hubbard stepped to the plate for the first time to face Astros starter Joaquin Andujar. For the season, Hubbard was batting just .168 in 51 games, with no extra-base hits and just one RBI, and he was making his first start at second base since July 31st.
The first Fast-Action card was out of Andujar’s PB range of 2-7, which put the forthcoming at-bat result onto Hubbard’s batting card. The next FAC card I turned revealed a Random number of 31, and when I went to check Hubbard’s card, I was surprised to find this:
Okay, now what? Do I award Hubbard a double or triple, or do I allow his card to remain in an endless state of transitional uncertainty? A quick online check of Hubbard’s stats told me that, during the actual 1978 season, he collected four doubles, no triples, and two home runs, which checks out with the numbers—and lack thereof—on Hubbard’s card. But where should that missing 31 go?
Thank you once again, Avalon Hill! I decided that, logically, it shouldn’t go in the triples spot, since he’d hit none in ’78, so I was left with a choice between a double and a home run. And because he’d hit just two homers that season, that one HR number on his batting card seemed appropriate, so I decided to assign Hubbard a double, which was still good enough for his first extra-base hit of the SP78 campaign.
So how would you have made the call? I guess a fourth option would’ve been to just turn over another FAC card and check a new Random number, but looking back, I kinda wish I’d given him a triple, which would’ve been his first in the major leagues, and no doubt the only one he’d collect for the remainder of the SP78 season.